Logo
  • CAKE MENU

  • Sugar is proud to offer a variety of delicious cake flavors that feature different flavor combinations that have been perfectly paired for your enjoyment.

  • Classic Flavors

  • 48 hour ordering notice or more to guarantee date reservation. However, we can often accommodate an order with less notice so please call to inquire. We also offer a selection of cakes available for walk-in purchase. Writing, buttercream flowers or buttercream balloons included in price. Edible photo; additional $15.00 to base price of cake.
    Gallery

    • 6" round, serves 8-10, $25
    • 9" round, serves 16-18, $40
    • 10" round, serves 25-30, $55
    • 12" round, serves 35-40, $70
    • 1/2 sheet, serves 60-70, $110

    Cannoli

    Our signature and best selling cake flavor!
    2 layers of vanilla cake, chocolate chip cannoli cream filling, fresh whipped cream frosting. * Light color decor only due to fragility & moisture in fresh whipped cream.

    Strawberries & Cream

    2 layers of vanilla cake, a light and fresh strawberry mousse filling, fresh whipped cream frosting. * Light color decor only due to fragility & moisture in fresh whipped cream.

    Boston Cream

    2 layers vanilla cake, chocolate ganache and Boston cream filling, fresh whipped cream frosting. * Light color decor only due to fragility & moisture in fresh whipped cream.

    Double Trouble

    2 layers of chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream filling & frosting

    Neapolitan

    1 layer chocolate cake, 1 layer vanilla cake, strawberry mousse filling, vanilla buttercream frosting

    White & Black

    2 layers of vanilla cake, chocolate buttercream filling & frosting

    Black & White

    2 layers of chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream filling & frosting

    Plain Jane

    2 layers of vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream filling & frosting

  • Gourmet Flavors

    • 6" round, serves 8-10, $35
    • 9" round, serves 16-18, $50
    • 10" round, serves 25-30, $65
    • 12" round, serves 35-40, $85
    • 1/2 sheet, serves 60-70, $130

    Reese’s Riot

    2 layers chocolate cake, Reese’s peanut cup butter cream filling, chocolate buttercream frosting, chopped Reese’s & chocolate ganache drizzle

    Cookie Dough

    2 layers of vanilla cake, chocolate chip cookie dough cream filling, vanilla buttercream frosting, cookie dough bites and chocolate ganache drizzle

    Oreo Explosion

    2 layers chocolate cake, Oreo mousse filling, vanilla buttercream frosting

    Red Velvet Cannoli

    2 layers of red velvet cake, signature chocolate chip cannoli cream filling, fresh whipped cream frosting. * Light color decor only due to fragility & moisture in fresh whipped cream.

    Red Velvet

    2 layers of red velvet cake, cream cheese filling, whipped cream cheese frosting. * Light color decor only due to fragility & moisture in fresh whipped cream.

  • Gluten Free* Friendly Flavors

  • *: Made with all gluten free ingredients. Please note that all Sugar products are produced in a common facility that does contain allergens (wheat, eggs, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, etc.) and are not certified to be free of any of the above.

    • 6" round, serves 8-10, $40
    • 9" round, serves 16-18, $60

    Gluten Free Friendly Cannoli

    2 layers gluten free vanilla cake, signature chocolate chip cannoli cream filling, vanilla buttercream

  • Drip Cakes

  • 72 hour ordering notice. Personalization available.
    Gallery

    • 6" round, serves 8-10, $50
    • 9" round, serves 16-18, $85
    • 10" round, serves 25-30, $115
    • 12" round, serves 35-40, $150
    • 1/2 sheet, serves 60-70, $250

    Chocolate Birthday Party Drip

    2 layers of chocolate cake layered with chocolate ganache and chocolate mousse, chocolate buttercream frosting, chocolate ganache ‘drip’ or colored white chocolate ganache ‘drip’, chocolate cake balls, adorned with your choice of primary or pastel confetti sprinkles

    Birthday Party Drip

    Our most popular Drip Cake Flavor… 2 layers of vanilla confetti cake layered with our creamy vanilla buttercream and sprinkle filling, vanilla buttercream frosting, white chocolate ganache ‘drip’ in the color of your choice, adorned with vanilla cake balls, adorned with your choice of primary or pastel colored confetti sprinkles… The perfect cake for your next birthday celebration!

    Oreo Drip

    2 layers of chocolate cake layered with Oreo mousse filling, Oreo buttercream frosting, chocolate ganache ‘drip’, adorned with chocolate covered Oreo’s

    Cannoli Drip

    2 layers of vanilla cake layered with our signature chocolate chip cannoli cream, vanilla buttercream frosting, chocolate ganache ‘drip’, topped with mini chocolate covered cannolis